What’s the Real ROI of “Authenticity”?
As brands compete to look culturally fluent, few are asking the deeper question: what does authenticity actually return?
About This Series:
Culture Is Capital is a series for people building the next era — brand owners, strategists, investors, creators, and anyone serious about where real culture is heading.
If you care about moving with culture, not just marketing to it — you’re in the right place.
Let’s go!
In every pitch deck and brief, the word “authenticity” appears like a non-negotiable.
Campaigns must feel real.
Brand tone must sound human.
Creative work must “come from the culture.”
But somewhere along the way, authenticity went from a principle to a performance.
And now, in a world flooded with sponsored moments, short-term collaborations, and curated community partnerships — the value of real connection is harder to define, and even harder to sustain.
So what’s the actual return on authenticity?
Short-Term Hype vs Long-Term Equity
Let’s start with the obvious:
“Authentic” campaigns often win attention.
They feel fresh.
They activate emotion.
They spark social currency.
In the short term, they generate reach — sometimes even revenue.
But the real test of authenticity isn’t how something looks in the moment.
It’s how it lasts when the spotlight moves on.
Culture isn’t a launch strategy. It’s a system of memory.
And brand equity isn’t built from exposure — it’s built from behaviour.
When “Real” Becomes Rehearsed
Too often, authenticity becomes a veneer:
The same creator partnerships repackaged across brands
The same campaign slogans reshuffled into new “manifestos”
The same imagery passed off as insight
Instead of rooting ideas in real proximity to people, brands reverse-engineer authenticity from trend reports.
The result?
Creative work that sounds like it gets it…
but doesn’t feel like it lives it.
The Hidden Cost of Surface-Level Authenticity
Audiences might not have the language for it — but they feel it.
Every time a brand misses the mark, partners with the wrong voice, or shows up only when it's convenient, it trains communities to distrust them.
Over time, this erodes something deeper than numbers:
Permission.
Permission to be in the conversation
Permission to try again
Permission to be part of the next cultural movement without being side-eyed
Once that’s gone, no budget can buy it back.
So What’s the ROI?
The return on authenticity isn’t always immediate.
It’s not always tied to a spike in conversions.
And it rarely fits neatly in a Q1 report.
But here’s what it does return:
Cultural proximity — the kind that can’t be faked or fast-tracked
Community trust — not just from creators, but from the people around them
Narrative ownership — where your brand isn’t just mentioned, but remembered
Future relevance — because when the cultural tide shifts, only those rooted in the ecosystem still stand
Real Wins Still Matter
This doesn’t mean authenticity is above strategy.
Done right, it leads to real outcomes:
Sales. Loyalty. Brand love. Legacy.
But the most effective “authentic” campaigns don’t just tick cultural boxes.
They ask harder questions:
Are we showing up for the community when it’s not campaign season?
Are we building infrastructure, or just awareness?
Are we listening to the culture — or scripting it?
Because the ROI of authenticity isn’t just about how loud your brand sounds.
It’s about whether people still believe you when the volume drops.
✍🏽 Gundeep Anand
Culture Architect | Platform Builder | IP Strategist